The militarization of Canadian Culture
The Hill Times, April 9, 2007
by Murray Dobbin
Harper government is trying to make 'mission' in Afghanistan defining
characteristic of who Canadians are. With no public debate,
we now have a war-fighting military taking up more and more
political space in Canada's constellation of defining institutions.
It is stunning how quickly the Canadian military can be recast as a key part of
Canadian culture, especially now that we have abandoned our historic peacekeeping
role. With no public debate, we now have a war-fighting military taking up more and
more political space in Canada's constellation of defining institutions. The military
and the Harper government are trying to make "the mission" in Afghanistan a
defining characteristic of who we are.
Militarization of Canadian Culture
The militarization of Canadian culture reflects the spread of "deep
integration"-the Bay Street initiative whose aim is to see Canada effectively
assimilated into its behemoth neighbour. Harper and others on the right know that in
order for Canada to adopt policies similar to those of the United States, we have to
make the cultural changes that will provide the ideological base for those policies.
When we first sent some 2,000 troops to Afghanistan, it was a major
assignment-not strictly peace-keeping, but not war-fighting either-and yet it rarely
made the news. But ever since we took on the war-fighting role in Southern
Afghanistan, our mission has become a major part of our daily cultural consumption.
And our approach in the country apes the Americans'-witness our government's
cavalier attitude toward the routine torture of Taliban prisoners seized by Canada
and turned over to the Afghan government.
Which brings us to a crucial point-this deliberate attempt to shift our cultural
landscape could not be happening without the complicity of the media, who have
become willing partners in this remaking of Canada. Regarding the prisoner scandal,
the Canadian media might never have dealt with the issue at all were it not for Amir
Attaran, a University of Ottawa law professor, who exposed the issue of Canadian
abuse of detainees in a letter of complaint he sent to the Military Police Complaints
Commission.
Professor Attaran obtained information about three detainees via a freedom
of information request. (Shouldn't it be the media who chase down these stories?)
When the commission tried to find the detainees in question, they had disappeared.
Media Misinforming Canadians
The media rarely expose what goes on in Afghan detention centres. One
story in a major daily newspaper dared to talk about what torture and human rights
abuses actually entail by referring to a U.S. State Department assessment.
That report stated: "Security and factional forces committed extrajudicial
killings and torture ... [including] pulling out fingernails and toenails, burning with hot
oil, beatings, sexual humiliation, and sodomy."
Why is it there is no comparable Canadian report? Because the Canadian
government knows that if it acknowledged the crisis in governance in Afghanistan,
Canadians would realize that the whole effort in that country is doomed to failure
and built on a foundation of lies.
The media are virtually silent on the issue-and worse. In late fall of 2006, the
CBC began implementing what seemed to be an explicit policy shift to build up the
image of the military and downplay any negative aspects of the war. Peter
Mansbridge hosted several newscasts directly from military bases in Canada that
were nothing more than public relations boosts for "our troops."
And although the CBC has dedicated considerable resources to covering
Afghanistan, it rarely acknowledges that its reporters are "embedded" with the
Canadian military, and that what they report, in my opinion, seems largely spoon-fed
by military public relations officers.
What happened to the CBC mandate to provide Canadians with genuine
debate about critical national issues? Where are the stories about corrupt and brutal
Afghan police? About internal refugee camps with no facilities or medical care?
About foreign aid disappearing into the pockets of officials? About the fact that we
can no longer fund other foreign aid projects because Afghanistan absorbs it all so
we can support U.S. foreign policy?
This situation reveals how naive we are as a nation. That old adage-the first
casualty of war is truth-applies here in spades because this war is based on lies,
including:
1. This has nothing to do with oil and gas pipelines.
2. This is a fight against terrorism. (The truth: It's an occupation being resisted
by indigenous militants.)
3. The current Afghan government is democratic. (The truth: Many senior
figures should be tried for war crimes, and others are drug lords.)
4. Girls are now going to school. (Really? How many?)
5. Bombing villages will provide them with security.
6. We can "win."
Corruption Haunting Canada
What we are doing in Afghanistan is unsupportable. But what we are doing to
ourselves is not so obvious. We are corrupting Canada's own institutions, including
our military, our foreign service, our foreign aide program, and our public
broadcaster. Worst of all, as long as we stay in Afghanistan, we are corrupting our
political culture.
====================================================
Note: For many years the United States has always viewed Canada as an
integral part of its territory. The ruthless control Americans are exercising over
Canada is revealed in how they managed to make the Canadian government
becoming an integral part of US belligerent policies. All of this is being done behind
the back of the entire Canadian population. The Canadian press has increasingly
become a tool of propaganda through the promotion of deceit and deception as
carefully demonstrated toward the end of this enlightened write-up.
Besides, the Canadian press, following the footsteps of the American press, is
hiding from the people the atrocities that their soldiers in both Afghanistan and Iraq
have been performing against innocent civilians. Canadians should demand from
their government to bring all Canadian troops from Afghanistan and Iraq home right
now. All government officials who continue to support war venture policies with the
USA should be ousted from their office in the next elections. Canada should focus
only on becoming an island of peace in North America same way as Costa Rica
became an island of peace in Central America.
To this end, Canada should sever all military relations with the United States
and concentrate instead on the development of the civilian economy. It should not
allow any US bases on its territory under no circumstance whatsoever and finally
Canada should take the initiative to develop an international program of
disarmament and arms control, of the dismantling of all nuclear weapons and of the
abolition of all landmines. This way Canada would prove to be a blessing not only to
the Canadian people but also to the entire world.
Contact us
with comments, questions, sponsorship requests and media queries.
Send email to gdufour@globalcommunitywebnet.com with
questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2006 Global Community WebNet Ltd.
|